1821 Guatemala NG M 8 Reales NGC VF35 undergraded?? Great original toning!

Description

Lovely "original" piece. 10+ years ago holder NGC VF35... I usually roll my eyes hard at sellers saying "undergraded" or "old holder - upgrade?"- they never say "geez, this grade was a gift!", do they?? - but I think this is a solid 40 or maybe even a stretch to 45 on a liberal day. Perfectly pleasant original patina... only issue of note is an ever-so-slight rim bump at 3 o'clock obv at the R in GRATIA, shown accurately in the pic. It's old, toned with the rest of the coin and not terribly distracting. Did they net grade b/c of it? I don't think so - I just think they whiffed.
Anyway, coin is as shown/advertised - no BS, no returns, U.S. buyers only for now, sorry. Pleasing coin!